Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Austin Olive's avatar

Rod Dreher recommended that his readers come over here. I did, and I'm glad. Thank you for your work here.

For my part, I've been desperately hoping that some governor would do something like this for over 30 years. I'm 49 now, and I've been paying attention to politics since Carter-Reagan in 1980. (My dad was a Goldwater man in '64, and started me on politics early.) When I was a US History and Poli. Sci. major in college (started 1992) I saw the handwriting on the wall and have been hoping for what Greg Abbott did this week. Honestly, I had such a spring in my step yesterday (1/25/24) I surprised myself.

That said, it is astounding to me that this is happening and the MSN - and even the conservative outlets - aren't on this like white on rice. It seems like crickets.

This is the biggest news since 1861, as you note. It may turn out like the Nashville Convention of 1850, with some mutually face-saving detente. But just as 1861 was inevitable in 1850, something catastrophic is inevitable today.

Just as Mr Lincoln said of slavery, we cannot continue half Progressive, half traditional. Eventually the Union, to be preserved, must become all one thing or another. That said, I don't see how that can be resolved without conflict. Lord willing, that conflict will not be a second civil war.

But do you see a way that we CAN resolve it otherwise? I cannot. We are facing 'soft totalitarianism' (per Dreher) or hard from the Progressives. Either way is unacceptable.

I'm at a point where I fear a failure of will to resist by the states today will, like the South's failure to act in 1850, guarantee that we lose down the road. Had the South stood up to Washington and the Yankees in 1850, we would have won. And we would have won without the stain of secession over slavery (as in 1860).

If conservatives do not stand up now, while resistance is still feasible, and on this issue, which is noble, I fear that our future issue will be less honorable, and at a time less likely to succeed.

I would appreciate your thoughts.

Expand full comment
Odinyrus of Baravia's avatar

Echoing Austin Olive here. Found you via Dreher, (of whom I’m a huge fan). Was looking for some meaningful analysis of this crisis all day today, and this is by far the best. Incredible work, and I’m looking forward to reading your previous post and your future work.

Expand full comment
11 more comments...

No posts